Every Year After Episode 1 Review: "Every Summer After" — Percy Comes Home, Meets Sam Again, and Finds Out He Has a Girlfriend

By Mira Vance · Editor & Lead Reviewer

Every Year After* opens with a toast that sounds like romance and lands like a dare. Percy Fraser can stand in front of a room and describe love as something you hold onto forever, but one phone call from Barry's Bay still sends her into a panic attack on a bathroom floor. "Every Summer After" builds the ache cleanly: the lake as first home, Sue's death as the reason to return, Sam as the person Percy has spent ten years trying not to face.

Percy toasts Chantal and Drew, then Charlie calls with news about Sue

The episode starts at Chantal and Drew’s engagement celebration, with Percy doing exactly the thing she says she hates: public speaking. Her toast is polished enough to hurt. Love, she says, is lonely to search for and difficult to keep. If you are lucky enough to find the person who celebrates your “madness and intensity,” you should never let go.

Then she steps offstage and proves she does not quite believe herself. Jake clocks the toast as almost convincing, Percy admits she writes obituaries for a living, and Chantal reads the room when Percy starts drifting toward Jake anyway. Percy can name devotion beautifully, then reach for the person least likely to ask anything real of her.

Charlie breaks that pattern with one call. He has not spoken to Percy in ten years. Sue, his mother, died of lymphoma a few days ago. The news is sad enough on its own, but the line that undoes Percy is smaller: Charlie says he thinks Sam wants her there too. Percy does not make it out of the bathroom before the panic hits.

Chantal pushes Percy toward Barry’s Bay after Percy admits Sam was the love of her life

The best present-day scene in the premiere is Chantal sitting with Percy after the panic attack, refusing to let her treat avoidance as a personality. Percy names the place she used to call home and the people she hurt. Chantal names the last decade more sharply: five years of panic attacks, five years of hooking up with men like Jake, and all of it wrapped in the lie that Percy does not care.

Percy’s answer is the key to the hour: she cares; she just thinks she does not deserve better. She says her world is filled with regret because of her choices and how things ended with Sam. She calls him the love of her life, says she cannot move on, and decides she needs to say goodbye to Sue, Barry’s Bay, and finally Sam.

Drew quietly becomes useful here, too. Chantal cannot drive Percy because of work, so he offers to take her instead.

Young Percy arrives at the lake and Charlie introduces her to Sam

The first flashback is all summer light and awkward timing. Arthur welcomes “Persephone” to the lake, Diane tries to help her find girls her age, and Percy heads for the water instead. Charlie and Sam are already there, turning a race to the dock into a sibling argument. Charlie does the social work Sam will not do, shows up at Percy’s door, and announces that Sam was wondering if she wanted to play.

Sam denies it immediately. Charlie clarifies that he wants his younger brother out of the way because friends are coming over, Sam overshares about shared bathrooms and hookups, and Percy agrees anyway. Percy is lonely and trying not to sound like it. Sam is curious and trying not to look like it. Charlie is already moving people around the board with half a grin.

Back in Barry’s Bay, adult Percy tells Chantal she feels 18 again, complete with the regrets. The town is small enough to make every old version of herself feel waiting at the next corner.

Percy and Chantal reach Barry’s Bay, where Delilah and Jordie make every old wound public

Percy wants armor before she sees Sam. Makeup, hair, a controlled entrance. Barry’s Bay gives her the opposite. She bumps into Delilah in a shop while holding hastily bought underwear, learns Delilah now has a husband named Whit and a house on the point, and finds out Delilah is close enough to Charlie and Sam to know Sue’s memorial details.

Delilah is not openly cruel. She is polished, local, and quick to remind Percy that she has been gone. Charlie appears, Delilah notices the charged space, and Chantal extracts Percy before the humiliation can settle into a full panic.

Then the motel deepens the bruise. Chantal expected a hotel, there is only one room, and Jordie pretends not to remember Percy even though she says they used to hang out with Sam. Chantal reads the snub correctly. Percy reads it even worse: Jordie was Sam’s best friend.

Charlie reaches Percy in the lake while Sam learns his brother invited her

Running with Chantal does not clear Percy’s head; the lake does, until it does not. She swims out, gasps, and Charlie reaches her in time. He tells her he has her. She admits coming back is harder than she thought, then says she cannot run or swim from what she did.

Her question to Charlie is simple: does Sam hate her?

At the house, Sam is already raw from Sue’s death and from Charlie’s uneven help. The brothers argue about care, absence, cereal, and the kind of grief that turns ordinary cabinets into evidence. When Sam realizes Charlie invited Percy without telling him, the hurt turns physical enough for a splinter and quiet enough for a confession afterward. Percy, Sam says, was not only his girlfriend. She was his best friend. She was family.

Young Percy and Sam trade pierogi, horror movies, and a bracelet he never wants to take off

The strongest flashback in “Every Summer After” is the kitchen scene at Sue’s. Percy eats pierogi like she has found a new religion. Sue promises sweet ones when rhubarb is in season, teases Sam about horror movies, and asks Percy to help with the dishes. In a few minutes, Sue feels like the warm center of a house Percy desperately needed.

Then Percy and Sam talk. She asks where his dad is, awkwardly because she does not know better. Sam tells her his father is dead, that it was a heart attack, that one day he was throwing Sam off the dock and teaching him poker and the next day he was gone. Percy apologizes, and Sam says he is glad she asked because people no longer talk about him.

It is friendship turning into trust in real time. Earlier, Sam offered pierogi in exchange for a friendship bracelet. By the end of the scene, Percy has finished one for him, and he says, I’m never taking this off. She answers the same. The line belongs to two kids who do not know yet that forever is easy to promise at the start of summer.

Percy comes to The Tavern, washes dishes with Sam, and meets Taylor

The reunion finally happens at The Tavern, over running water and dirty dishes. Sam sees Percy and says, “You came home.” She apologizes twice. He tells her it is okay, then tells her she is comforting him by being there. They do not try to solve ten years in one conversation. Percy just asks to help, and the help is dishes because Sam was always bad at them.

The quiet does not last. Delilah tells Charlie that The Tavern is being sold to her, and Charlie has not told Sam yet. That secret sits beside another one, because Percy has returned to say goodbye to the past and immediately walks into a present she did not imagine.

Taylor enters looking for Sam. Sam introduces her as his girlfriend. Percy says hi. Taylor is kind. Nobody does anything wrong. That is what makes the moment sting. Percy came home to a grieving man with a life, a girlfriend, and a whole decade she missed.

Tiny details worth clocking

• Percy writes obituaries for a living, so she is professionally trained to turn a life into a controlled paragraph.
• Sue calling Percy “sweet P” in the flashback gives Percy’s grief a family shape before the present-day memorial even starts.
• Chantal’s hatred of the motel is comic, but her willingness to share the room is the practical version of friendship the episode keeps valuing.
• The bracelet exchange is two lonely kids making proof that somebody chose them.
• Sam’s anger over the cereal cabinet is really anger over who was there for Sue and who was not.

Final verdict

“Every Summer After” is a strong premiere because it trusts the lake-house memory without sanding off the adult damage around it. The flashbacks have dock races, horror movies, pierogi, bracelets, Sue making room for a lonely girl. The present has panic attacks, awkward hellos, a motel room with one bed, and the hard fact that grief does not pause just because first love walks back into town.

Delilah and Jordie put a little neon around the social stakes. Both scenes work, but the stronger material is quieter: Percy trying to breathe in the lake, Sam admitting Percy was family, and the two of them washing dishes because that is the only safe language left between them.

As a first episode, it makes Percy and Sam’s past feel worth grieving before it asks us to care about their present. It also gives Sue enough life that her absence is not just a plot trigger. She is the reason Percy comes back, the reason Charlie calls, and the person who once told Percy that her racing thoughts were part of what made her amazing. That is a clean, bittersweet place to begin.

Rating: 8.4/10 — A tender, grounded opener with sharp friendship detail, a lived-in lake setting, and just enough present-day mess to keep the nostalgia honest.

More episodes from Every Year After — Second chances and old summers, episode by episode. Jump to any episode in the season:

Reviewed by Mira Vance · QuizFandom Editor & Lead Reviewer. Every rating is an honest per-watch assessment from the desk that also writes the quizzes — not a press release rehash.

← All Every Year After reviews